Writing
Groups: A Search for Fellowship
by Hamilton Mac Alester
(from The Market List #4)
Are you looking for other writers like yourself? If you're
reading this, you already have access to one of the best
resources available to a writer. Online writer's groups
and workshops offer opportunities for learning, socializing,
and career advancement, all from the comfort of your own
home.
These writer's groups come in three flavors: social, structured,
and informal. Each has benefits and drawbacks, depending
on what you're looking for in a group and your skill level.
The
Social Group
The social group is generally a collection of writers or
interested persons who meet according to a schedule and
discuss their areas of interest.
Pros:
This is a great place to meet writers in the same field(s)
you're interested in. As in any endeavor, networking with
your peers is invaluable. You can learn about current market
trends, projects others are working on, and what the best
coffee is when you really need to stay awake. Group's like
this are also good for relating your own experiences and
learning about the experiences of others--which can remind
you that, though you may write alone, you are not alone
in writing. These groups often contain more published writers
than other groups, though many published writers won't identify
themselves.
Cons:
Aside from socializing with fellow writers, these groups
offer very little to further a writing career. Stories are
not critiqued, nor can you always depend on the advice and
comments you hear. Turnover is high, making it difficult
to develop "relationships" with other writers. Often, discussions
digress to the same level of chat you can find in any general
interest chat room.
The
Structured Group
The structured group has specific requirements for membership,
like critiquing two member stories a month. When these groups
meet, they follow formal agendas and use a protocol structure.
Pros:
Members of these groups are usually more serious about their
writing than what you find in a social group. Writing tips
and activities are of a higher caliber. It's also a great
place to get your own writing critiqued by a large group
of writers in your genre. The critiques you do for others
teach you how to break stories down, figure out why they
work or don't work, and see other plot, setting, and characterization
styles. This alone offers more than many writing classes
can, because you learn by doing, and can apply that knowledge
to your own writing. Besides, it costs a whole lot less.
The core members of these groups are often very knowledgeable
in the genre, providing specific advice on markets, editors,
and agents. These groups also attract guest "speakers" which
include published writers, editors, and agents.
Cons:
Turnover in these groups is high, and the caliber of people
varies greatly. The waiting list for critique dates can
often exceed four to six months, and the quality of critiques
varies with the caliber of the people. Some members do a
very minimum job, or make comments that are, to put it mildly,
discouraging. Beginning writers often do not know the rules
of writing, nor when they should be ignored. More advanced
writers sometimes forget what their early writing was like,
and are too harsh on beginners. And there are the members
who join only long enough to get a story critiqued and then
drop out. A major concern with these groups is that it is
very easy for them to become nasty and counterproductive,
so choose structured groups with care.
The
Informal Group
You won't find these groups advertised. They are smaller
reading groups formed by members of the larger structured
groups, or by writers who know each other. They sometimes
have set standards, but are more often a collection of like-minded
writers.
Pros:
Membership in these groups is kept small, so everyone knows
everyone else, and support is plentiful. Turnover is low,
creating lasting relationships, which are very important
for social and professional development. Prolific writers
get quick feedback on short stories and novel chapters,
without worrying about doing a specific number of critiques
to remain a member. Marketing information is more specific,
often involving a specific editor's actions in regard to
a specific story.
Cons:
This is a personality-driven group. You must choose motivated,
dependable people or it will fall apart. Even with dependable
people, the number of critiques you receive back on a given
submission are few. A bond of friendship can even be detrimental
if you feel so obligated to critique someone else's work
that you sacrifice time from your own.
These are the three flavors of writing groups. Beginning
writers exploring cyberspace for the first time should start
by attending open chat sessions and social gatherings. You'll
learn online etiquette, and discover where the structured
groups are and what people think of them. When you're ready
for a structured group, attend its meeting and watch the
group interact. If you're still interested, join. Informal
groups generally form among writers who have developed a
mutual trust and interest.
Writing groups are one of the best writing resources available
to you. Choose them with care, participate, and watch your
writing career take off. On America Online, go to keyword:
Writers.
--------------------
Hamilton
Mac Alester (hamilmac@aol.com) runs Mind Flight, a fifteen-member
informal writer's group on America Online, and is a member
of the AOL Science Fiction Writers Workshop.
Copyright © 1996 by Hamilton Mac Alester. All Rights
Reserved. |