The Market List Interviews
Q & A with Jeff VanderMeer
by Shauna Skye
(from The Market List #5)
Jeff, I have your biography in front
of me and it looks as though you've been busy both as a
writer and a publisher. Some of our readers may already
be familiar with your work; but for the benefit of those
who aren't why don't you begin by telling us about The Ministry
of Whimsy, what it is, and how it came about?
The Ministry of Whimsy is a literary organization
I founded in 1984. The name was chosen as a take-off on
the novel 1984 with the intent of publishing work
that was not in fact "whimsical" - read "frivolous" - but
serious and thoughtful. There's also a sense of play in
what we publish, of course, and the name serves as a double
meaning for those who remember the novel 1984 and
those who do not. I started Ministry of Whimsy because I
wanted to get into publishing, but I didn't want to be restricted
to doing one thing. Under the Ministry of Whimsy umbrella,
I've published two magazines, Chimera Connections
(which published a couple of National Book Award winners)
and Jabberwocky (which published early Kathe Koja,
Wayne Allen Sallee, and others), and now, with Mule Press
in Canada, Leviathan, which is clearly superior in
every way to anything I've ever done before. Ministry has
also published chapbooks, newsletters, and sponsored readings,
workshops, and presentations both here in Tallahassee and
in Gainesville, Florida. Some of the readings/presentations
have been by such heavy-hitters as the late Judson Jerome
and the NYT nonfiction bestselling team of David and Barbara
Neel. [Shauna--this seems to go on too long--please feel
free to cut this one especially down to size]
As an editor, what do you
look for in your submissions. Of course, all editors want
a "good story" but what are some specific things that you
like? In your opinion, what constitutes a "good story?"
This is the most difficult question you
can ask me, because so much of what I do as an editor is
predicated on what I don't like. In other words, my first
responsibility to the "slush pile" is to find those things
I dislike or which I know are not right for the particular
project I'm working on. Then I'm left with a small number
of interesting manuscripts, all of which may be completely
different. So any answer I give you will be by definition
limiting, especially since I believe that my own strength
as an editor is my ability to appreciate many different
styles and schools of writing. That said--and I know I'm
taking the long way around to answering your question--I
generally look first for style and voice: is the writing
interesting. If the writing itself on a line-by-line level
is generic, then I'm not interested. And I don't mean that
the writing must be flowery or gaudy--it can be stark and
muscular--but it must in some way show that the writer has
individuality. Next, does the story support the style; in
other words, has the story substance, or is it simply pyrotechnics
with no point. Depending on the type of story, this can
mean do the characters engage my interest?, or it can mean
any number of other things. Finally, does the story have
that element of transcendence, of spirituality, that quality
of otherness which hints at inspiration. (By spirituality
I do not mean religion.) Of course, these elements change
when you are discussing a humorous story, and I do not mean
to suggest that these elements cannot reside equally in
a mainstream literary story, a mystery story, or a genre
story. But the absolute bedrock, the foundation, is the
way a writer treats the English language and how that writer
makes the language his or her own.
All right Jeff, what is
it you dislike in a story and/or submissions? Do you have
any pet peeves that our readers can take note of?
This is the easy question. Any genre conventions--vampires,
werewolves, zombies, serial killers, fairies, elves, etc.--just
bore me to death. These are pet peeves--and will lead to
immediate rejection. "Immediate rejection" is when I read
only one or two pages and put in a form rejection--this
occurs when there are more than two grammatical errors on
a page; it also occurs whenever one of the pet peeves listed
above are combined with an awkward style or a hackneyed
plot. I would estimate that 50 percent of the form rejections
I give are due to grammatical errors (if the writer can't
use language properly, there's no point in reading the whole
manuscript) and another 45 percent are from hackneyed situations
or sending inappropriate submissions (such as vampire, werewolf,
etc. stories). The other 5 percent are divided into stories
that are bad for some other reason, and stories that simply
don't fit the particular project I'm working on. When I
edit a project like Leviathan, I have a particular
vision in my head of the final "shape" of the book, and
especially when you've accepted three or four stories toward
that "shape" or "architecture" it's easy to tell which good
stories you're considering will fit and which will not.
A certain consistency was particularly important for Leviathan
where we mix mainstream and fantasy fiction. I wanted readers
to be able to read all the way through without a loss of
continuity--in other words, the reader should believe that
all of the stories could take place within the same "world,"
and I mean "world" in a very general sense.
You've been published in
Asimov's SF Magazine, Worlds of Fantasy and Horror,
and other professional markets. What advice would you give
an aspiring writer who is trying to break into the market
and finding it difficult?
My sales to Asimov's especially
have been unusual to say the least. I've sold the editor
material which only has a hint of fantasy, or none at all.
The editor, Gardner Dozois, will sometimes take material
that is not clearly sf or fantasy, but in fact material
that is teetering between genre and mainstream. This is
pretty symptomatic of all my sales--I sell stuff too weird
for mainstream and too mainstream for weird to those magazines
willing to take a chance, sometimes literary markets, sometimes
genre markets. I sold a mainstream relationship story to
the anthology Dark Terrors in the U.K., for example!
My main advice would concern tenacity. I sent around 15
submissions to Asimov's before they took one. If
you really believe in your writing, keep banging your head
against the brick wall until the wall breaks or your head
does.
I know there are some poets
reading this, but I'm mainly asking this one for personal
reasons. :) Tell us about how you won the Rhysling Award
for poetry? And do you have any tips for the poets reading
this?
I used to write lots of poetry--it's how
I started--but I found I like narrative, telling a story,
more than capturing an emotion or a moment in time, which
I feel is the job of the best poetry. However, I was stuck
on a short story called "Flight Is For Those Who Have Not
Yet Crossed Over" which is from the POV of a guard in a
South American prison for political prisoners. So to unstick
myself, I wrote a poem of the same name about one of the
prisoners, whose dreams are so powerful (he was an artist
on the outside) that he literally wills himself to fly while
dreaming, but still cannot escape the prison because he
can't fly through the bars. The Silver Web published
it--it is the ONLY poem I've written in the last four years--and
Marge Simon, bless her heart, nominated it for a Rhysling
and it wound up winning (tying actually with a poem by Bruce
Boston) and will be in the latest Nebula Awards anthology.
As for advice for poets, I'm uniquely unqualified to give
advice in this department--I consider myself a failed poet.
However, I would say that anyone thinking of confining themselves
to writing sf/fantasy/horror poetry should think again--and
should read mainstream poets, not poets known for their
genre work exclusively. Most of them stink in comparison.
Tell us about the novel
that will be coming out soon. What's it called? What's it
about? And how we can get a copy?
Dradin, In Love is about so many
things--I threw in everything but the kitchen sink, frankly--that
all I can do is quote from the ad copy: "In a city that
has never existed, in a world that never was, the missionary
Dradin pursues his love, and in his pursuit embarks upon
a journey that will forever change him. A baroque, unforgettable
work of memory and imagination." I will add only that it's
fun, bawdy, colorful stuff, and to quote from the blurbs
in the ad again (shamelessly, I know): "A remarkable novel
of the obscure objectification of desire" - David Griffin,
Carnage Hall; and "A true masterwork of imagination,
skill, and creativity" - Mike Olson, fiction editor, Year's
Best Fantastic Fiction. You can get it from Buzzcity
Press, a cool independent publisher, for $11.50 postpaid,
at POB 38190, Tallahassee, FL 32315 (same publisher that
does The Silver Web). It's a really great-looking
limited edition with just incredible pseudo-Victorian collages
by Michael Shores. Perfect bound, colored endpapers--the
works. I'm very happy with the presentation.
Do you find it easier or
more difficult to write a novel rather than short fiction?
It's really more a question of how the
short story or novel is created. Dradin, In Love
(admittedly a rather short novel) came into my head one
night all of a piece--I knew almost every detail and I just
got up, wrote the first five pages and then in a torrent
of words got the rest down over the next week--about 35,000
words. The novel I'm working on now, Mapping the Beast,
is longer, admittedly, but the main reason it is harder
work is because I started out not knowing the ending. So
it's been a long, hard road via perspiration to get where
inspiration had gotten me on Dradin so much more
quickly. And, in this case, it is frustrating not to have
a completed rough draft in a few weeks. You feel as if you
are stuck out in limbo land and are unsure you'll make it
to the other side and safety. But some short stories have
taken literally years to write between the first idea or
image and the final draft.
Who are some of your favourite
authors (be they established or up-n-coming)?
Angela Carter, Angela Carter, and Angela
Carter, first of all. Her novels The Infernal Desire
Machines of Doctor Hoffman and Nights at the Circus
are magnificent, as is most of her other work. Others I
particularly enjoy are Mervyn Peake, Edward Whittemore,
Vladimir Nabokov (his Collected Stories is not just
great fiction, but a great fiction workshop--arranged chronologically,
they are a story of stops and starts, learning new technique
and using it awkwardly at first, using plots that were clunky
and then later seamless; any writer can learn a great deal
from this book), M. J. Harrison (unjustly under-rated),
Alasdair Gray (especially Lanark and Poor Things),
Mark Helprin (A Soldier of the Great War is one of
the best books I have ever, ever read), A.S. Byatt, and
the list goes on. Most of my favorites are individuals--they
belong to no school of writing, they appear out of nowhere,
and their works are eccentric masterpieces. Oh yes--and
we can't forget Bulgakov and his marvelous Master and
Margarita. As for contemporary writers (or up-and-coming),
I'd have to say first and foremost there's Stepan Chapman.
He has a novel, The Troika, which no one will publish,
that is one of the great fantasy works of the decade. Absolutely
magnificent. And his short humor/satire pieces are unique.
A master stylist. Also good is a writer named Nathan Ballingrud.
He's had one story in F&SF and one in The
Silver Web, but spends most of his time just writing
down in New Orleans in a tiny apartment, his days spent
as a bartender. He's 23, I believe, and his work is fantastic.
Mark the name, because I can tell you right now that he
will write some of the great works of the early 21st century.
What do think (hope) the
future holds for the Ministry of Whimsy? How about yourself?
The Ministry will start publishing a line
of No Frills Chapbooks in August which will highlight new
and established writers in an inexpensive format. The first
one scheduled is of Stepan Chapman's work--see, I put my
money where my mouth is!--and is called Danger Music.
We also intend to collaborate on the second volume of Leviathan
with Mule Press. The theme will be simply novellas, and
we'll look at any work over 10,000 words. However, we aren't
reading yet--we will probably begin reading in January of
1997. As for myself, I have a short story collection coming
out from Dark Regions Press in August called The Book
of Lost Places and I'm currently finishing a long novella
called "Quin's Shanghai Circus" which has been a very pleasant
experience. I also have short stories forthcoming in The
Silver Web, Dreams From the Stranger's Cafe,
BBR (both in the UK), and many others. I also have
a nonfiction column in Fantastic Worlds. And I'm
going to London for two weeks this summer--first time out
of the country in seven years!
Is there anything you'd
like to talk about that I neglected to ask? If so, the floor
is all yours.
Oh--I run a critique service which is rather
unique. I don't take repeat clientele. I expect that one
critique of a short story or novel will teach the writer
enough that he or she doesn't need to come back. Anyone
interested should write to me care of Leviathan. My rates
are reasonable because I love editing.
For those writers looking for good writing
books, I cannot recommend highly enough Revising Fiction
by Madden. No other book can match it.
Jeff VanderMeer
LEVIATHAN
Vol. No. 1
Into the Gray
"This is one of the best collections of
quality fiction at any level that I've seen in years. Not
since the early volumes of Damon Knight's Orbit series has
such a consistently well-written set of stories appeared
under one cover." - James Murray, Tangent.
Ten journeys into the unknown by superlative
storytellers from the mainstream and genre ranks. Stories
of adventure, relationships, psychological suspense, the
metafictional, and the metaphysical, by such writers as
Mark Rich, Stepan Chapman, Ursula Pflug, and Doug Rennie.
For the eclectic reader who craves the new, the strange,
the different. Unlike any anthology currently published
in its coherent mix of writing styles and subject matter.
Cover by World Fantasy Award winner Alan M. Clark.
160-page trade paperback, only $8.50 postpaid
($9.50 foreign) from: Leviathan, POB 4248, Tallahassee,
FL 32315
Copyright © 1996 by Shauna
Skye. All Rights Reserved. |